Maxfactor Colour Perfection eyeliner is great! The sharpener on the end isn’t very good and clogs really easily but that’s the worst thing I can think of with it so it can’t be that bad!
I use it on my waterline and it stays on all day. It fades a little but it doesn’t smudge or anything. It goes on dark grey at first but after going over the lines a couple of times it goes to a really good black.
It’s fairly resistant to water too. It does run a little with tears but it wipes off really easily with the hand.
It works better when not blunt for some reason.
It retails for around £5 which is good for the product. I will buy this again once it runs out but it’s lasting a long time too.